What is the difference between Pilates and Clinical Exercise & Pilates Based Rehab?

Return to Blog Articles
Clinical Pilates

What is Pilates…? Especially Clinical Pilates…

In the world of working out, Pilates on large groups to pumping music is now high fashion.

Once the best-kept secret of the dance community, Pilates has been discovered and embraced by singers, models, athletes, actors and wait for it….normal people!! But what exactly is Pilates about…especially Clinical Pilates?

We always have many interesting and valid questions centred around the question of core stability and its role in Pilates and musculoskeletal rehabilitation.

As Physiotherapists and Clinical Pilates Instructors, our evidence-based practice is intermingled between manual and movement therapy. Firstly, we address the injured structure using evidence-based medicine, then improve its function by recovering muscle activation, joint stability then strength.

Pilates plays an important role in rehabilitation of most injuries by improving muscle activation and joint and trunk stability before moving to traditional strength and conditioning exercises.

Pilates is also great at making sure your body is moving well.  Perfect for improving posture, reducing injury risk if you plays sport, strengthening your joints and bones as we age or conditioning your body for your next adventure.

At the outset, it is important to understand that there are two distinct types of Pilates which you may come into contact with.

The first kind is ‘Fitness’ Pilates, offered through a variety of classes at the gym, leisure centre or community hall, or available on YouTube.

The second type is ‘Clinical’ Pilates, which has become increasingly integrated into mainstream medicine and rehabilitation.  This discipline is usually taught one-to-one, or under very close supervision within a small group, as part of a patient’s rehabilitation from injury or addressing areas which need work.

Has Fitness Pilates lost the plot?

In an effort to grow rapidly as an industry, Fitness Pilates is in danger of becoming its own worst enemy.

Speaking from experience: working as a physiotherapist in the sports and fitness industry, we hear weekly about the injuries created in Pilates classes by well-meaning instructors with upwards of 15 people in their care. The most common complaint is an increase in low-back pain.

The last thing that is going to help this sort of pain is loading it repeatedly in a flexed position with exercises that are uncontrolled and more often than not too hard. Something very common in large group classes.

Unless you all have the same complaint, the same bodies or a Physio who understands certain conditions, doing the same program as the person next to you is just simply not the best idea.

So why join a Physio led smaller group?

If you define core stability purely in terms of ‘strength’ (such as it is used in the fitness industry and in large group Fitness Pilates) and limit it to being region specific (i.e. trunk musculature only), then the myth of core stability is rampant.  Tighten all of your ‘trunk’ muscles and notice how you feel and how your movement is.  For most people, it feels limiting and stiff.  Any good Physiotherapist will tell you that the body works as an integrated whole and holding a plank for 5 minutes will not cure nor prevent back pain brought on by 1 hour of sitting!

Clinical Pilates is largely concerned with training local spinal and pelvic stabilising muscles to work efficiently throughout functional activity. Clinical Pilates seems to have filled the gap between moving away from “hands-on” manual treatment to addressing the neuromuscular system associated with the onset, persistence, and reoccurrence of pain. Because of the nature of Clinical Pilates, it is seen as being particularly important for people with spinal pain amongst other motor control problems and is associated to what researcher’s term “specific stabilisation exercises” or “motor control exercise. Clinical Pilates has become an important tool for many Physiotherapists in answer to the spinal stability research that has surfaced over the past decade.

Clinical Pilates should among other things:

–        Improve Stability

–        Increase flexibility

–        Make you more durable

Whilst the foundation stone of Pilates is the concept of core stability. A stable trunk, or mid-section, is the best platform from which to develop whole-body muscular strength and endurance (durability), balance and flexibility.

Having a stable ‘centre’ allows one to move efficiently with good technique. It should minimise tissue overload, correct alignment and muscle imbalances and therefore reduce injury risk.

Hence, muscle and joint stability is the key prerequisite for the efficient development of muscle flexibility and durability. And the principles and equipment of Clinical Pilates help to achieve this better than most, if not all, other exercise systems.

So why Clinical Pilates?

It is a great balanced way to approach exercise: ensures that no muscle group is overworked; and teaches the body to operate as an efficient system in sport and daily activity. Efficient and resilient bodies can be less prone to injury.

The key to getting the most out of your Clinical Pilates is having a great instructor.

And the key to being a great instructor is accuracy and specificity.

  1. Accuracy

Accuracy relates to how Pilates is taught: the type of exercises and the context.

The success of the system relies heavily on the careful education and monitoring of a client by a correctly trained teacher.

The question must be asked: does the advantage of teaching 30 clients in a class outweigh the disadvantages of 50 per cent to 90 per cent of those participants getting it wrong?

From experience, we know that it can take up to 30 minutes of one-to-one attention and direction from us before a patient learns to isolate and activate the correct muscles for even one new movement pattern.

And then they must practise it!

One-to-one training is the best medium and must remain the basic initial learning tool to learn to use the “core muscles” correctly.

Small groups of no more than 4 or 5 is the next step.

  1. Specificity

Specificity relates to what is being taught.

We are talking about the critical word in exercise philosophy here: you get what you train for.

So, if you as a client are doing Pilates and strengthening the wrong abdominal muscle group, you will probably get good at tensing the wrong muscle, but never achieve correct stability.

Or if you have not been shown correctly how to move around your pelvis in order to hold a neutral spine, your brain will learn an incorrect movement pattern and your body may be setting itself up for injury.

The greater the specificity, the greater chance of success with our goal to deliver an effective exercise program.

Conclusion

The power of Pilates lies in the detailPhysiotherapists are experts at observing and correcting movement.

The specificity and accuracy of Clinical Pilates make it such a potent tool for anyone interested in maintaining peak physical conditioning as well as a great rehabilitation instrument.

Was this insightful?